Thứ Sáu, 10 tháng 7, 2009

The Shindig

At first glance, The Shindig is just another all-singing, all-dancing Mickey Mouse cartoon, featuring Mickey and the gang playing music in a barn and dancing up a storm. But if you look a little deeper, there’s something very interesting going on in this cartoon.

This was directed by Burt Gillett, so I don’t know if what I’m noticing was his doing or the animators, but there is an undercurrent of a subversive nature to The Shindig. There are a couple examples that really stand out to me, but I’m certainly open to see what you guys think.



The first thing I noticed right away was the opening scene, which features a carload of animals heading to the dance. I noted above that this short was basically just Mickey and Minnie dancing in a barn, very similar to the earlier short The Barn Dance. So it struck me to watch this to see the front of the car labeled with “To the Barn Dance.” Was this an intentional way of the animators informing the audience that this short would be something they have seen before?



I sincerely doubt it, since they had no way to know that the audience would have seen the earlier short. But was it something the animators put in to refer to the earlier work? I have to think it was. They could have phrased that a few different ways, but calling it “The Barn Dance” is telling, at least to me.

The second thing is when Horace Horsecollar goes to pick up Clarabelle Cow. He pulls on her tail outside the shack where she is, then the camera goes inside the shack. Clarabelle is lying on her bed, reading a book entitled “Three Weeks.” Again, at first glance, not that significant. Clarabelle goes and puts on a skirt to cover her udders and basically “clothes” herself. This is the first time we’ve seen her wear clothes.



Put the pieces together, though, and it seems a little more unseemly. The book Clarabelle was reading was a banned book at the time, because it was an account of a Balkan queen seducing a young British aristocrat. Author Elinor Glyn received a lot of trouble for the book. To have Clarabelle “naked” on her bed reading a piece of “erotic” fiction seems a little out of the ordinary for Disney.



There may be nothing to these two instances, but they did stand out to me. Add to that the fact that this short reuses a lot of animation. Sequences of Mickey and Minnie playing music, Minnie at the piano, Clarabelle and Horace dancing, and the crowd applauding are all reused at least once, and some are used three times. Sure, that is probably due to the production schedule, but could it also have been an animator protest at having to do the same type of short again?



I know all this is wild speculation, but hey, that’s half the fun, right? In truth, there probably was nothing going on in The Shindig other than some fun gags and turning out another quick Mickey short. We see some new uses for Horace and Clarabelle here, and Patricia Pig even turns up again. But it’s fun to look at this short and its gags and possibly see that animators may be tired of the same old thing as well. Who knows?

All images copyright Disney. All rights reserved.

Thứ Năm, 9 tháng 7, 2009

Arctic Antics

Arctic Antics is a rather, well, silly entry into the Silly Symphonies, but it does have some interesting features. There are a couple of nice experiments with motion and perspective, and the appearance of a polar bear that looks very familiar.

The basic outline of the short is exactly what it says, the antics of arctic creatures playing, dancing, singing and eating on ice flows and glaciers. Like most of the Silly Symphonies, there is no narrative flow besides the music carrying things along. It’s not a detriment to the shorts most of the time, but Arctic Antics does lack a bit of cohesion.



The beginning sequence, featuring a polar bear cub riding on the back of a white seal, is quite good, and features some very interesting motion. The cub jumps over ice flows, while the seal goes underneath, and the cub lands back on the seal on the other side. It’s a cute gag, but the real interesting thing is the way the seal is drawn while underwater. Again using the techniques from earlier Silly Symphonies, we get to see the animators trying something new with viewing a character through the water, not just their reflection. This is a natural extension of what we saw in Springtime, with the frog viewing his reflection.

The next sequence is an interesting set of details as well. While various animals float right to left in the foreground, joining in the song where appropriate, the back ground animals stay put, dancing and singing. It’s very neat to see two different speeds of motion in the same shot like that. It’s not something you would expect, but it works very well.



Of course, the most memorable piece of Arctic Antics has to be the appearance of the “Mickey” polar bear. It’s not surprising that the animators would reuse model sheets or repurpose characters, due to the amazing time crunches they were under on these films. It is surprising, however, that they would do so with the studio’s most recognizable character. There’s no doubt audiences would see this little guy as a Mickey clone, so it’s a mystery as to why they would insert him.



There are few smaller sequences between the Mickey bear and the last major set piece, but they’re fairly unremarkable. A walrus is used as a bass, a seal plays with his food of a fish to entertain other seals – nothing very new or innovative, and not particularly entertaining to me.



The last part of the short, though, is dedicated to a group of penguins marching along to the old song “Parade of the Wooden Soldiers,” and that’s quite fun. There is a smaller penguin unable to keep up to provide some comic relief, but the whole thing is quite good. The music is peppy and keeps things moving, and the penguin animation is done quite well.



Arctic Antics will probably mostly be remembered for the Mickey bear, but to me, the penguin sequence is the best part of the short. As a whole, though, there’s not much new here to interest a repeat viewer.

Thứ Tư, 8 tháng 7, 2009

The Fire Fighters

Mickey’s latest short, The Fire Fighters, is a great use of the character in his new role as the loveable loser. The bravado filled Mickey of the early shorts would not have worked in this cartoon, but Mickey as the hapless fire chief works really well.

To be fair, this is really a remake of Alice the Fire Fighter, the 1926 short that featured a team of Julius clones tackling a burning hotel building and rescuing Alice. Replace Julius with Mickey and Alice with Minnie and the storyline of the shorts are pretty much the same. The difference here are the strides that the Disney animation team have made in the four years since the Alice short was made.



For one thing, the gags are outstanding in this short. From the beginning scenes of Mickey and his fire team asleep in the firehouse to the climactic rescue sequence, there are gags every few seconds that are very funny. There are some classics, like Mickey inhaling and drawing a spider closer to him as he sleeps.



One of my favorites was the end of the alarm sequence, after all the crew has awakened and slid down the fire pole (really an ostrich). The camera pans over to a long bed, where we see the ladder waking up and watch it go through the paces to get on the truck. Animating the ladder as a character is a touch of genius, and very funny.



The gags don’t stop there, as Mickey and crew get to the fire site, but can’t get the hydrant to work. It merely dribbles water out. So, Mickey turns it into a cow’s udder shape, and “milks” the water out. But, Mickey isn’t the best fire fighter in the world, and spills the water on the way to throw it on the building, not once, but twice! It’s a hilarious turn of events.



Mickey’s personality is great in this as well, showing his frustration with the hydrant or the fear of whether he’ll be able to save Minnie or not. He really is a character here, not just a collection of drawings, and that’s the way he’s been evolving throughout this period.



The short ends with a familiar gag, of Mickey falling to earth, using large bloomers as a parachute while he cradles Minnie. It’s a great visual, and it’s been used many times by the Disney team, but it’s still a nice, sweet gag. The twist here is that when they reach the ground, Mickey and Minnie poke up through the legs and have a kiss.



The Fire Fighters doesn’t have any major animation advancements or turning points in Disney history. It does, however, have a tight narrative and a load of great gags. That makes it a winner in my book!


All images copyright Disney. All rights reserved.

Thứ Ba, 7 tháng 7, 2009

Frolicking Fish

At first glance, the Silly Symphony entitled Frolicking Fish is not all that remarkable. It’s merely a peek at some fish dancing underneath the waves, being menaced occasionally by an octopus. But when you look closer, you can see a real breakthrough in animation for the Disney artists.



Norm Ferguson, a former New York animator who joined the Disney team fresh off of the Aesop’s Fables cartoons produced by Paul Terry, had the task of animating a trio of fish. This was an easy task for someone of Ferguson’s skill, and there was a tried and true method of doing motion or dancing in the shorts to this point.



Under Ub’s tutelage, the Disney animators were taught to draw motion in poses. The animator would draw movement up to a pose, then hold the pose for a few frames before moving again. This led to some very dynamic images, with the “poses” being held in the audience’s sight. That left a definite impression on the audience.



However, Ferguson chose to do something different. He made the decision to skip the poses and keep the motion flowing, which was definitely a risky call. It worked beautifully, however, and his trio of fish have a very fluid motion and smooth movement that Walt was enamored of immediately. Walt ordered the other animators to study Ferguson’s style.



The other notable aspect of Frolicking Fish is the main villain, the octopus. His movement in this short is also remarkable. The octopus pops out of an old treasure chest, and begins menacing the fish. But his tentacles are rapidly spiraling in and out, backwards and forwards, in a flurry of motion that is very well done.



The octopus continues in a tradition of Silly Symphony villains that have come before, like Satan in Hell’s Bells or the lion in Cannibal Capers. The octopus is an equal to those, menacing the fish in several ways before a fish manages to escape and drop an anchor on its head. The resulting ink excretion from the octopus provides the fade to black at the end of the short.



Other than the octopus and Ferguson’s motion, there’s not much to discuss. Frolicking Fish, like most other Silly Symphonies, lacks much of a narrative. Not that having a story is always necessary, but there are no characters to latch onto, like there are in the Mickey shorts. Without a main character or a narrative flow, it’s difficult to really get into this short, although it is entertaining for what it is.

Thứ Hai, 6 tháng 7, 2009

The Cactus Kid

The Cactus Kid, the latest Mickey short, is really just a remake of The Gallopin’ Gaucho, but it has some distinct differences that make this short very memorable. The main difference is in Mickey himself, which shows you how much has really changed in Mickey from his first appearances in 1928 to 1930.

The storyline of this short is very familiar – Mickey enters a cantina that is inhabited by Minnie. After some great dancing and musical performances, Pete enters, with his eyes set on Minnie. After a confrontation with Mickey, Pete kidnaps Minnie, and Mickey gives chase. Mickey manages to knock Pete off his horse and over a cliff, leaving he and Minnie to look over the cliff and wave goodbye.



It’s a simple story, and very much like The Gallopin’ Gaucho, but what’s interesting is the change in Mickey. In Gaucho, Mickey is a swaggering bundle of bravado, who enters the cantina through the window, drinks a beer and smokes a cigarette. He’s rough around the edges and grabs Minnie to dance, not asking permission.



In Cactus Kid, however, Mickey enters through the door, after riding in on Horace Horsecollar. He meekly enters and joins Minnie in a song, not joining in the revelry with a drink or cigarette like last time. He plays music with her, and when he gets a little fresh, tweaking her nose, Minnie fires back, throwing plates at him.

The old Mickey would have been more forceful, but this version of Mickey instead takes a couple of mugs that Minnie threw at him and uses them to do a Mexican dance, using the mugs as castanets. It’s quite the change from the mouse who grabs the girl and forces a kiss like he did in Plane Crazy and Gallopin’ Gaucho.



There are some good pieces of animation here, especially in Mickey’s personality. When he confronts Pete, you can see the courage or fear on his face depending on whether he has the upper hand. Right after that, there’s a great sequence where Pete knocks out the lights, and we only see the action through flashes from the muzzles of the guns the two are firing at each other.



The finale sequence is very much a retread of past Disney cartoons, with the horse chase echoing scenes from the Alice Comedies and Oswald. Mickey extends Horace’s neck to walk over and jump on Pete, just the way the other characters did in previous shorts. But the overall effect of having a Mickey that is more shy and somewhat of a loveable loser is a good one. It makes Mickey more relatable and interesting than the bravado Mickey, at least in my eyes.



I have to say though, that it would have been interesting to see the more aggressive Mickey in some of these later cartoons. How would things be different today if Mickey had continued down that path? Obviously, Walt felt that the public preferred this version of Mickey to the original version, but it would have been a very neat experiment to see the original version carried through.

Thứ Năm, 2 tháng 7, 2009

Night

Cannibal Capers, the first Silly Symphony cartoon after the departure of Ub Iwerks, was a very different cartoon, featuring some nifty camera moves, less reliance on animals and silly dances, and some disturbing subject matter. Apparently that didn’t work, because the latest Silly Symphony, Night, is a return to previous form.

I’d almost classify Night as an unofficial part of the “Four Seasons” quartet of Silly Symphonies, because it falls very much in that same vein. This time, rather than a season, the short examines what happens as the moon rises over a pond. Of course, it’s all set to music, but there’s a slight difference in this short.

The short’s tone is set right off the bat by a full moon rising over the pond, that then turns into a buck toothed singer. The moon’s singing is comically bad, and that sets the stage for a plethora of off key singing to follow. We get bad songs from owls, mosquitoes and frogs, all involved in activities of love or pursuit of happiness.



The action flows from scene to scene very well, much in the same way that it did in Springtime or Autumn. We go from the moon to the owl flying over the scenery, to the lightning bugs flying by, to mosquitoes underneath and finally to the frogs the mosquitoes try to sting. It’s very fluid and gives the short a nice sense of being a continuous short instead of a collection of gags.



I’d be remiss if I did not note the artistic merit of the opening scene, showing the long shot of the moon rising over the pond. It’s a beautiful piece of work, and the reeds and waves on the pond move and sway in time with the music. That just makes it all the more entertaining when the camera zooms in to the moon and it turns around to reveal its silly face.



Another interesting bit was the lightning bugs, who at first perform a dance in the sky, alternately lighting up to do a nice light show. But next, we see two bugs performing a vaudeville soft shoe. I can only imagine that these two bugs are pulled right out of Walt’s head, reflecting back on his days as a kid performing vaudeville with Walt Pfeiffer. Just an interesting peek into Walt’s psyche, I think.



We also see in this short the return of the frog from Springtime. It was noted then that this frog was similar to Flip the Frog, who would later become Ub Iwerks’ cartoon star. The frog is back here, and one has to assume it was based on the same model sheets that Ub developed for the previous short. I wonder if we’ll see him again, after Flip the Frog has debuted?



Night is entertaining, but it does feel somewhat like a retread. The gags are good, but not as funny as in other shorts. It feels very much part of the “Four Seasons” group, as I mentioned above. I think Walt and his crew did a great job of animation on Night, but could have used a little more humor to make this one truly great.

Thứ Tư, 1 tháng 7, 2009

The Barnyard Concert

Can a short be derivative if the short you compare it to came after it, not before? I’m joking of course, but it’s unavoidable to watch The Barnyard Concert and not compare it to The Band Concert, Mickey’s first color short and one of his best. The Barnyard Concert pales in comparison to the latter feature, but it’s still got some good material.



This short is again basically an excuse for Mickey and the gang to play some music, but it features Mickey in his conductor role, that he will revisit later in The Band Concert and some other shorts, as well as in the parks in Mickey’s Philharmagic. It’s really quite a legacy if you think about it.



From the point Mickey takes to the soap box to conduct the band, it’s mayhem. The animals are all playing instruments this time, which shows a bit of the growth in the animators and Walt. Remember back to earlier shorts, when the band would be playing on makeshift instruments made out of spare string or even other animals? Now we are looking at fine horns or violins or bass. It’s quite the change, although subtle if you have not been watching all of these shorts in a row.



There are some repeat gags here, such as Mickey yanking on piglets’ tails to make some music, just as he did in Steamboat Willie. There are also a couple of familiar looking characters that make up part of the band. Recognize these two?



To my untrained eye, it looks like an update of the cat and dog characters from the Laugh-O-Gram Films days. It’s kind of neat to see little touches like this that harken back to the olden days of Disney cartoons.

The other thing that continues here from Just Mickey is the stellar work on Mickey’s expressions. One that stands out is his expression of disgust when a pig with a trumpet keeps interrupting the symphony.



Just looking at the expression, you can see the horror at the bad note and irritation at being interrupted. There are other instances in the short, such as his angry conducting and happy dancing. All of it makes Mickey a very memorable character, full of personality, in a way that none of the earlier Disney creations were.



The Barnyard Concert is a good short, with some fun gags, but it’s not groundbreaking or a high point of Mickey’s career. It does show some advancement though, however incremental. From the addition of real instruments, the personality of Mickey, and the detail in the drawings, you can definitely see a bright future for Mickey’s cartoons based on this short.


All images copyright Disney. All rights reserved.